New profile trend

edited March 2018 in General

I've seen a trend growing in the profiles created or updated in the past 6 months or so and wonder where it came from and why it's gaining so much traction. People are saying, "my friends would say I am..." or "my family think I am..."

Why do people think it's informative to say what they imagine others think of them or what others have said of them? Wouldn't it be better to just say what they think of themselves? A third party's opinion is pretty much meaningless to me since my tastes and values are likely different than theirs just as people's opinions of movies and foods have no sway over my own opinions of those things because I recognize that we are different people.

A third party's view (real or imagined) rather than a personal view is just another level of removal from what we're trying to share in our profiles: information about ourselves. A person's opinion of themselves is still not going to heavily influence my own opinion of them, but it at least tells me something about them by giving me their own perspective rather than someone else's.

It's like playing the telephone game. The closer to the origin of the information, the more accurate and meaningful it is. And "I think I am..." is closer to the source than "I think they think I am..."

Where did this trend come from and what do you think of it? And, no, I don't want to know what you think someone else thinks of it; own and share your own opinions. :P

Comments

  • [Deleted User]DarrenWalker (deleted user)

    I think it's an attempt at objectivity (or the appearance of it, anyway).

    "I know perfectly well I'm biased in my opinion of myself. Perhaps my ideas of who and what I am can't be trusted. But other people might not be as invested as I am in thinking that I'm one of the most wonderful human beings who ever lived, and so their opinions might be more trustworthy."

    That sort of thing.

  • It's been a thing in online dating sites since I guess the start of online dating... some don't know what to say and instead say what they think their family/friends would say about them followed by building off that thought. Why it's seemly showed up here more recently?.. no idea, but most people will admit to being horrible when describing themselves.
    Also, 2 points to cover...
    1. the person you are in your head isn't necessarily the person others think of you as
    2. the more you look for something the more you'll notice and find it.. the brain wants to find patterns

  • Actually, I think it's simpler than all of that. If I recall correctly, one of the prompts that appears when new members are first filling out the "About" section in their profile is "What would your friends say about you?" Although designed as a source of inspiration for people with writer's block, it seems many just directly reply to the question. Now I'm tempted to make a new temporary profile just to see if I'm right, LOL.

  • @quietman775 you are right! I was just about to add that myself lol

  • That is correct, the prompt is there and a lot of people just answer that question because they don’t see it as a suggestion or a profile starter but more as a requirement.
    I never liked it though and I agree that the profile description should come from a more personal place.
    Maybe it’s time to take the prompt out and see what people come up with.

  • MarkMark Mod
    edited March 2018

    "How would your best friend describe you? Why do you like to cuddle? How do you cuddle?"

    Open to suggestions on the above. I do think some sort of prompt is beneficial for such a niche website in order to avoid many people getting instant writer's block.

  • Could just be that they enjoy referring to themselves in third person...

  • Just answering the prompt. @Mailleweaver It looks like you signed up a while ago, so maybe forgot. Or maybe you just didn’t interpret the prompt the same as others do. Plus, if a new member sees another’s profile written that way, he is more likely to do the same, I would think. @pmvines makes a good point as well.

  • It's just simply in response to the question asked when creating your profile.

  • edited March 2018

    The prompt didn't affect me because I don't currently have any friends to say things about me. In fact, I think the prompt's presumption that everyone has a best friend could be offensive to some people who might be coming here to find a best friend.

  • Yeah, that prompt could definitely explain how widespread it is. Perhaps it could go more along the line of "Think about what you would look for in a cuddle buddy and share that information about yourself here: What type of person are you looking for, and do you think you have those traits yourself? Why and how do you like to cuddle?"

  • Originally I ignored the prompt, but then i was asked that question by others, and was prompted by another pro to utilize the prompt, so i added it in. It's not unhelpful info, but it's helpful to get more info, too.

Sign In or Register to comment.