The MOST important rule on the Internet

I feel like with all the advice going around it's time to remind people of the most important rule of the internet:

DON'T TAKE ADVICE* FROM PEOPLE ON THE INTERNET

Why?

1 . Because people on the internet can only give advice from their experience. This makes them biased. Not only in how things should be done but in how things normally go wrong.

2 . People who care enough about a topic to post about are likely people with strong opinions. That means their views are more extreme than say most lurkers. (The vast majority of people). Similarly people who give unsolicited advice are often really just passive-aggressively complaining.

3 . People on the internet are either anonymous or have their reputation amongst hundreds to millions of people at stake. When people are anonymous the advice they give is often less "how things work irl" and more "how i think things should work". So, if they are completing a wish fulfillment scenario wholesale, they still may be giving advice that doesn't match reality. Likewise people who are not anonymous would like to make sure that they aren't seen poorly. This means they can be dishonest or misleading in order to save face. Even if they're truthful, you can expect the information to be biased to show them in a positive light.

4 . Internet people are not real people! Personalities of people who you have to interact with in everyday life are often entirely different than they way they seem online. I have personally experienced this. Presenting an authentic version of yourself with only text is a skill. Even then, people interpret text differently.

5 . The advice is not tailored to you. Most people on the internet haven't met you so the advice will only apply to the type of person they see most often (which itself is a bias). Not only that, the person giving the advice may err on the wrong side of caution. For example, telling you "to add more salt than you think you need" assuming that you normally under-season your food. If you typically over-season your food, your dish will be not only ruined but perhaps dangerous.

6 . You don't know the person giving the advice. The person giving you pointers may not even be the type of person you would want advice from. In real life, you can see if they have expertise in the area they advise in. You'd probably know if their cakes always turn out dry, for example. On the internet, you kinda have to take their word for it. Even if their advice gives them results they like, you may find out you wouldn't enjoy being in their situation.

So, what does this mean?

This means that when you receive advice on the internet take it with a grain of salt. ESPECIALLY, when it comes to human interaction and relationships but also any cause where success is subjective.

Relationship advice (work, friends, partners, etc) is particularly heinous. Your personality doesn't just affect you. It affects the people you attract and the people you repulse. It is one of life's great ironies that people afraid of commitment attract people afraid of being alone (and vice versa). Advice from either type is likely to be bad especially if you don't lean to being the same type as the advice giver. This isn't the only case. People with low education are more likely to meet people with low education. People with disposable income are more likely to meet people with disposable income. The location of a person can affect not only how many people around them have negative traits but WHO is more likely to have those traits and WHAT those traits are likely to be. And again, THOSE WITH NEGATIVE EXPERIENCES ARE MORE LIKELY TO COMPLAIN ABOUT THEM. They're also more likely to assume that those experiences are the norm (which may be true for them and the the friends they chose but not for you, the person taking the advice).

The real rules for success human interaction and this site are simple: Set firm boundaries for yourself and let them be know explicitly, respect and know the boundaries of others, and ask for permission before you act. Or in French, "communicate for once".

*This especially applies to any advice about interactions with other people.

  1. So?15 votes
    1. That's some good advice, internet stranger!
      53.33%
    2. What? That's terrible advice! I refuse to take it.
      46.67%
«1

Comments

  • edited January 2021

    I believe everything I read on the Internet and trust everything from keeping up with the kardashians. That’s just obviously facts.

  • Everything on the internet is true -Abraham Lincoln

    @Importance

  • I'd like to take your advice... but dang... I'm reminded of the time this person on the internet told me not to take advice from people on the internet.

  • ☝🏾☝🏾☝🏾

  • @LovenLight he must be a wise man.

  • I invented the Internet and global warming — Vice President Al Gore

  • @BotWithFeelings He most certainly is! Which is why I heed his advice so strongly!

    @Importance Wasn't he "President-elect Al Gore" at one point? O yea nm

  • edited January 2021

    Probably. @Lovelight

    Internet facts!

  • @Importance FYI You tagged the wrong person... Or did you?

  • Seems like a horrible thing to invent, maybe he just likes the beach

  • @LovenLight i see what you did there 🙃

  • Hmm, i thought there'd be more pizzazz in this thread.

  • [Deleted User]DeadGirlWalking (deleted user)

    I feel like this is a not-particularly-subtle response to my thread 'Parental Advice'...

  • @BotWithFeelings I think you made some good observations. I'd say the advice you gave applies to advice given IRL to a lesser extent, though in IRL it's easier to determine the motivations behind that person's advice.

    I remember a thread that @Importance started I think, had to do about arousal while cuddling. Most of the posters in the thread said they would be prefer not to be aroused. While Importance said there were many people PMing her that arousal while cuddling is something they do enjoy. So this is evidence that falls right under 3 and 2. I think this point is especially important for this forum because fellow cuddlers you might try to message may see a controversial statement and filter you out based on that.

    There are tidbits of wisdom to be found on the forums here and there that I seemed to find helpful.

  • @BuggleBear it isn't. I wrote this let it sit, made some edits and then posted. Only to find that someone (you i guess) had just posted the opposite.


    @sunnysideup certainly tidbits of wisdom exist. Discerning what is wisdom and what just sounds wise is the challenge.

  • [Deleted User]DeadGirlWalking (deleted user)

    No, mine was posted a day before yours.

  • edited January 2021

    @BuggleBear Well I certainly didn't see it. Trust me, it is a unsubtle jab but not at you or your thread. I really on care about the advice people give for cuddlecomfort for example advice on "how men can get more partners".


    EDIT: @BuggleBear I just checked the dates. They are both Jan 14. Perhaps you forgot we're in different timezones?

  • edited January 2021

    ^^ I guess this is just another example of how easily advice can be misconstrued on the internet haha. @BuggleBear I too initially thought it might have been in response to the parental advice thread lol.

    The old saying,

    When you Assume, you make an ASS out of U and ME.

  • [Deleted User]DeadGirlWalking (deleted user)

    @BotWithFeelings even with taking the time zones into account, pretty sure mine was posted first.

    @sunnysideup it was a fair assumption.

  • edited January 2021

    @BuggleBear well doubtless. The thread was already popular by the time I posted. I didn't dispute that (though I can see how what I wrote could be unclear). I just didn't know your thread existed. As far as I can tell the advice in that thread is most harmless and generic anyway.

    Edit: typos

  • edited January 2021

    @BuggleBear For sure! You were not the only one, I was also confused haha. I can now see that BotWithFeelings is directing it at the threads that re-appear every now and then involving personality/relationships that can get pretty opinionated.

  • edited January 2021

    Which brings us back around to the point of people lie on the Internet. Or they just post things that they believe to be true and that are completely false.

  • @Importance not me but most people yes

  • edited January 2021

    Are you saying that I should take your word over the words of keeping up with the Kardashians?

    Let me just recap. We should not trust anything on the Internet unless it is you.

  • @Importance yes. Hold steadfast to my words and astray you shan't be led. So, says I the internet stranger.

  • Wait you mean it's not Be careful what you Google because rule 34 is very much a thing?

  • On a different website I'd have a different response. @NightShift39

  • On a different website I'd have made a more twisted comment heh

Sign In or Register to comment.