Ladies and gentlemen let's stop messing around and decide your fate.
Team Nutella!! Team Peanut Butter!!! Team Cookie Butter!!
Can't beat a classic, going peanut butter.
Cookie butter is great but being flour based... Smearing it on bread seems perverse.
Nutella is good in small doses. Too sweet to be the only thing on bread/toast.
Ideally thin layer Nutella one bread, thicker layer peanut butter other slice of bread and sandwich.
can we mix all three together? 🤣
Move this one to the lounge please. Gonna be a bloodbath in here.
I love crepes, so Nutella is my choice. A fresh warm crepe with a thin layer of Nutella is heaven. Nutella is great in homemade ice cream, I add melted Nutella to my ice cream base.
@Pasquia a bakery out here did Nutella birthday cake for a limited time
Nutella, if from Europe. Peanut butter, if from the US.
They each have their place in the world. I refuse to choose one when they each have their specialty things 😂
I use Reese’s peanut butter baking chips to make peanut butter fudge and it is unbeatable.
I mean, idk if I’d choose any of those for my birthday lol but I am a sucker for peanut butter 🙌🏽 Peanut butter toast with slices of banana and drizzled with honey with a sprinkle of cinnamon FOR THE WIN!!!!
I cannot choose just one! It really depends on the application! Crepes— Nutella and bananas and strawberries! Toast it’s peanut butter and honey like how @BrokenWillow does it/- absolutely delicious by the way Icecream or cheese cake it’s the biscoff cookie butter. And if I’ve just had an edible it’s all three on icecream!
Cookie butter?! I haven't even heard of this, so I don't think I can be an accurate critic 🤔
@BrokenWillow Thanks for the inspiration. Making a peanut butter, banana , honey and cinnamon sandwich today.
I prefer Justin's Chocolate Hazelnut Butter
@MomInShaMan Youre so welcome! You’ll love it and be hooked! It’s my go to midnight snack attack nom nom nom 🤤
@tranquilsoul See… you already know the power of all that deliciousness 🙌🏽
@FutureHeart2023 Boooo!!! None of the above.
Ok, seriously, what is this for? Cookies? Birthday cake? Toast? 👀👀
I can't believe peanut butter is winning in the polls.
@FutureHeart2023
I voted
Nutella and cookie butter are ok to me, just so sweet I can't deal unless it's small doses😂 I love natural PB. Amazing flavor, texture and aroma. 🙌
This is definitely a right tool for the job scenario.
Justins honey peanut butter.
Idea: Justins honey peanut butter, Nutella, marshmallow fluff on brown sugar cinnamon graham crackers. ^ I've never had that btw but in my head it just sounds good af and I hope someone tries it for me. 😂 I used to love peanut butter and marshmallow fluff sandwiches as a kid.
PB. But ONLY if it's smooth.
Well I never heard of cookie butter, don't like Nutella, so I'll have to go with peanut butter. I don't mind smooth or crunchy, but I also don't usually like things mixed in with it. Just straight peanut butter on toast or crackers and that's about it. Never was a fan of pb & J or Reese's (don't kill me lol).
Almond Butter for the win!
Never heard of cookie butter Also I don’t like peneats or Nutella so lolll
Okay well Im glad I'm not the only one who hasn't heard of cookie butter, I dunno I kind of think that might taste weird.
Although I have a sweet tooth
For me it's gotta be peanut butter, sugar or not (preferably not)
Cookie butter is Biscoff flavor
I wasn’t sure what to pick between peanut butter and Nutella. Until the question was raised about what would I pick on my birthday. Nutella to me is more decadent and more expensive so it seems like an indulgence. I never had cookie butter so I didn’t know what that was. After I voted I looked up cookie butter and I’m like OMG that’s like one of my favorite things of all time. Is that Cinnamon type Spice.
Trader Joe's sells cookie butter, @Bear 😊